Skip to content
ASME U & R Stamp · TEMA · NQA-1 Quality Program Call us: 800-767-9507
Harris Thermal
Products & Services Overview Shell & Tube Heat Exchangers Pressure Vessels / Tanks Other Fabrication Machining / Drilling Repairs
Industries Overview Oil & Gas Chemical Formaldehyde & Resins Pulp & Paper Food Processing Mining & Minerals Power Generation Nuclear Data Centers Water Treatment Sugar Processing LNG General Manufacturing
Capabilities Overview Fabrication Machining Materials Engineering Quality Control Safety Logistics & Shipping
Resources
About About Us Certifications Employment
Contact Get a Quote →
Home / Industry Insights / Heat exchangers for desalination and high-chloride water service: materials, corrosion, and design

Heat exchangers for desalination and high-chloride water service: materials, corrosion, and design

Published

Heat exchangers for desalination and high-chloride water service are often specified from the chloride concentration alone. Chloride makes pitting, crevice corrosion and stress corrosion cracking possible, but oxygen, chlorination, temperature, deposits and crevice geometry determine how severe the attack becomes. Those conditions, together with fluid allocation, cleaning access and joint design, govern service life, and most are fixed before a fabricator quotes the job.

IN BRIEF

  • Chloride concentration alone does not establish alloy suitability. Oxygen, residual chlorine, temperature, pH, deposits, crevice geometry and flow govern localized-corrosion resistance in a specific water.

  • Corrosivity varies within the same seawater. Biofilm and chlorination raise the corrosion potential of stainless steels and deaeration lowers it, so aerated intake water and deaerated brine may require different alloys.

  • PREN is a screening tool. It ranks base-metal pitting resistance from composition and does not account for welds, crevices, oxidants or stress corrosion cracking.

  • Titanium and super duplex have defined limits. Hot crevices limit unalloyed titanium, hydrogen uptake can embrittle it under specific thermal and electrochemical conditions, and welds often limit super duplex in chlorinated seawater.

  • Specify the whole wetted system. Tubes, tubesheets, channels, gaskets and piping connections form one galvanic and crevice system.

On this page: where exchangers fit · how chlorides attack · materials · shell-and-tube design · fouling and brine · equipment types · codes · common mistakes · RFQ checklist · Harris support · FAQs

Where do heat exchangers fit in desalination and high-chloride service?

Heat exchangers appear wherever a desalination or water-treatment process adds, removes or recovers heat:

  • Thermal desalination. Multistage flash (MSF) and multi-effect distillation (MED) plants evaporate seawater and condense the vapor, so heat-transfer surface is the process: brine heaters, stage and effect tube bundles, and condensers. MSF evaporators handle deaerated seawater, which shapes material choices.

  • Reverse osmosis (RO). RO separates salt with pressure and a membrane; its energy-recovery devices recover hydraulic energy from the reject brine. Exchangers sit at the edges: cooling an industrial feed hotter than the membranes allow, cooling auxiliaries, or recovering heat in hybrid thermal-membrane plants. DuPont FilmTec data sheets, for example, rate their polyamide elements for 113°F (45°C) maximum.

  • Brine concentration and ZLD. Brine concentrators, crystallizers, preheaters and condensers take RO reject or industrial wastewater toward solids in zero liquid discharge (ZLD) systems.

  • Seawater cooling. Coolers and surface condensers in coastal and offshore plants use seawater or brackish water.

  • Industrial reuse, chemical and mining service. Cooling tower blowdown, produced water and chloride-rich leach liquors bring the same mechanisms, often with added acidity, oxidants or scaling ions.

Plate, spiral and welded-plate exchangers compete with shell-and-tube equipment for several of these duties.

How do chlorides attack heat exchangers?

Chloride damages passive alloys locally, where their protective oxide film breaks down and cannot repair itself.

Pitting, crevice corrosion and chloride stress corrosion cracking

Pitting starts where the film fails at an inclusion or damaged spot; acidity builds inside the pit and chloride migrates in, so the pit sustains itself. Crevice corrosion follows the same chemistry in a confined gap: under a gasket, deposit or biofilm, inside a tube-to-tubesheet joint or at a baffle hole. Oxygen in the gap is consumed and not replaced, and Journal AWWA guidelines describe how chloride and free chlorine both intensify the resulting cell. Because crevice attack generally starts under milder conditions than pitting, crevice resistance usually governs alloy selection in seawater.

Chloride stress corrosion cracking (SCC) needs tensile stress, chloride and elevated temperature together. Austenitic grades such as 304L and 316L are the most susceptible common stainless steels. Evaporating or wet-dry surfaces concentrate chloride far above the bulk analysis, a mechanism Harris's exotic alloy guide covers in depth.

Why chloride concentration alone does not decide corrosion

Localized corrosion needs a cathodic reaction, mainly reduction of dissolved oxygen or, in chlorinated water, hypochlorite. A CORROSION 2011 paper published by AMPP (formerly NACE International), by engineers at a super duplex producer, reports that stainless steel potentials in seawater can span more than a volt. The range runs from stagnant deaerated water, where microbial corrosion is the main risk, to chlorinated flowing water, where crevice corrosion is.

In natural seawater, the authors describe biofilm forming within days to weeks and raising stainless steel potentials; chlorination raises them further. Citing earlier research, they report that biofilm did not develop where seawater was heated well above its local ambient temperature. That finding is tied to the conditions studied, and warm seawater is not benign: higher temperature lowers crevice-corrosion resistance in its own right.

Deaeration works the other way. The Journal AWWA guidelines, developed with the U.S. Bureau of Reclamation and the Water Research Foundation, note that stainless steels tolerate far higher chloride in fully deaerated water. They also state that no simple chloride or chlorine threshold guarantees freedom from corrosion.

Water conditionWhat drives localized corrosionDesign implication
Natural, aerated seawaterDissolved oxygen; biofilm raises stainless steel potentialCrevice resistance decides the stainless grade; gaskets, joints and deposits are the weak points
Chlorinated seawaterHypochlorite, a stronger oxidant; chlorine and chloride act togetherHighest crevice risk for stainless steels; state the chlorination regime in the RFQ
Deaerated seawater or brineLittle oxidant; stagnant deaerated water can support sulfate-reducing bacteriaLower-alloy choices hold only while oxygen stays out, including during startup, shutdown and air in-leakage
Concentrated brineHigher chloride, temperature and scaling-ion levels; deposits; cleaning chemicalsSelect for the hottest, most concentrated location and for the cleaning regime
Stagnant or idle waterOxygen depletion, biofilm and deposits in dead legs and undrained equipmentDesign to drain; specify hydrotest water, draining and layup

Table 1. Qualitative comparison based on the AMPP and Journal AWWA sources cited above; it is not a set of design limits.

Temperature, deposits, flow and shutdowns

Temperature is among the strongest accelerants, and the governing value is the metal surface temperature. The wall runs hotter than the water where the water is heated, as in brine heaters, evaporators and seawater coolers, and cooler where hot brine is cooled. It sits nearer the fluid with the higher film coefficient, so a steam-heated brine heater runs its brine-side wall nearer steam than brine temperature. Water-side deposits on heated surfaces raise it further. Material checks should use the wall-temperature profile along the exchanger and across operating cases. Low pH from acid cleaning or dissolved carbon dioxide narrows the passive margin. Stagnant water left after hydrotest or during shutdown can be worse than any operating condition, so idle periods belong in the corrosion design basis.

Galvanic corrosion

Seawater's high conductivity spreads galvanic currents over large areas. When a large titanium or super duplex tube surface is coupled to a small area of less noble metal, the small anode can corrode rapidly. TIMET's corrosion data show the attack growing with the cathode-to-anode area ratio. Coating holidays on carbon steel channels and mismatched weld filler create the same problem.

Which materials suit seawater and brine service?

PREN as a screening tool

The pitting resistance equivalent number (PREN) condenses chromium, molybdenum and nitrogen into one figure, most commonly %Cr + 3.3 × %Mo + 16 × %N. PREN ranks the base metal of similar alloys but does not describe welds, heat tint, intermetallic phases, crevice tightness, temperature or the water's oxidizing power, and it says nothing about SCC.

Laboratory results should be read as supporting evidence. ASTM G48 ferric chloride tests rank alloys by critical pitting and crevice temperatures under the method's own conditions. ASTM describes them as accelerated relative to most natural environments and notes exceptions to their correlation with service. ASTM G78, the guide for crevice testing in seawater, cautions against predicting service from a single test program.

MaterialSeawater and brine performancePrincipal limitationsFabrication and costVerify before specifying
Carbon steelCorrodes in aerated seawater; used in deaerated thermal-desalination shells with corrosion allowance, coatings or liningsGeneral, under-deposit and microbial corrosion; anodic to alloy tubesLowest material cost; protection adds inspectionOxygen exclusion; coating condition; cathodic protection effects on titanium
304/304LGenerally unsuitable for aerated seawater; in concentrated brine, suitability depends on oxygen, temperature and crevices and needs case-specific evaluationPitting, crevice corrosion, chloride SCC at elevated temperatureLow cost; widely availableOxygen control; chloride concentration at wet-dry and evaporating surfaces
316/316LBetter than 304L; generally inadequate for immersed seawater heat transferCrevice attack at gaskets, joints and deposits; chloride SCCLow cost; widely availableTreat seawater use as an exception needing specialist review
Duplex 2205Better crevice and SCC resistance than 316L; used in deaerated desalination service; limited in warm or chlorinated seawaterCrevice corrosion in oxidizing seawater; intermetallic phases from poor heat controlAt least twice austenitic strength; phase-balance control in weldingUNS S32205 vs. S31803; ASTM A923 testing where specified
Super duplex 2507PREN above 40; used for seawater piping and exchangers within temperature and chlorination limitsWelds often govern in chlorinated seawater; intermetallic phasesHigher cost; tighter welding windowsWeld procedures, post-weld cleaning, chlorination regime, temperature
6Mo austenitic (AL-6XN, 254 SMO)High pitting and crevice resistance in seawater and brineNot immune to crevice attack in warm, chlorinated seawaterHigher cost; good formability; filler choice mattersWeld filler, heat-tint removal, crevice design
Titanium Grade 2Very high resistance in seawater and most neutral brines; high erosion resistanceHot-brine crevice corrosion; hydriding, usually where heat, an unstable oxide film and a hydrogen source coincide, or under severe cathodic polarization even at ambient temperature; fluorides, reducing acidsHigh cost offset partly by thin walls; reactive-metal welding controlsHot crevices, galvanic partners, cleaning chemicals; Grade 7, 12 or 16 for severe crevices
Ni-Cr-Mo alloys (625, C-276)High localized-corrosion resistance; used where stainless grades reach their limitsCost; not immune to crevice attack in severe hot or oxidizing chloride serviceHighest material cost; often used selectively or as claddingWhether selective or clad use meets the need
Nickel-copper Alloy 400Distinct from Ni-Cr-Mo grades; suits flowing seawaterPitting and crevice attack in stagnant seawaterHigh material costStagnant, layup and low-velocity conditions
Copper-nickel (90-10, 70-30)Long seawater-cooling and thermal-desalination history; inherent biofouling resistanceErosion above design velocity; sulfide-polluted water; start-up practiceCost varies with metal pricesWater pollution, velocity, commissioning

Table 2. Relative behavior in seawater and brine service. Qualitative; confirm each selection against the actual water, temperatures, crevice geometry and cleaning regime.

Duplex, super duplex and 6Mo grades

Duplex grades offer at least twice the strength of their austenitic counterparts with equal or better corrosion resistance, according to a review in Desalination covering desalination applications. Oxidizing seawater is harsher. The AMPP authors attribute service failures of 22Cr duplex in seawater RO high-pressure piping to limited crevice resistance at the potentials found there. They identify welds as the usual limit for super duplex in chlorinated seawater, and their laboratory tests found a 6Mo alloy attacked in warm, but not cool, chlorinated seawater.

Heat input and cooling rate control intermetallic phases in duplex grades. ASTM A923 notes that meeting a product specification's chemical and mechanical requirements does not by itself show their absence. Weld filler, root profile and heat-tint removal matter on every stainless grade, including AL-6XN.

Titanium

Titanium Grade 2 resists general corrosion, pitting and erosion in seawater and most neutral brines, and TIMET's guide reports no known case of microbially influenced corrosion. Its limit in chloride service is crevice corrosion at elevated temperature. TIMET shows the onset shifting with pH and with calcium or magnesium content, and producers' published limits differ by test environment, so no single temperature applies. Grades 7, 12 and 16 extend crevice resistance where hot crevices cannot be designed out.

TIMET's guide also reports that hydriding failures usually need three conditions at once: a compromised oxide film, a temperature above about 170°F (77°C) and a hydrogen source. The film is compromised by pH below about 3 or above about 12, abrasion damage or strong cathodic polarization; hydrogen comes from a galvanic couple, impressed-current cathodic protection or corrosion. Coupling to carbon steel in neutral seawater generally does not generate hydrogen on titanium; zinc or aluminum anodes, coupling to corroding steel in sulfide-bearing water, or heavy overprotection can, the last even at ambient temperature. Galvanic coupling or cathodic protection therefore warrants evaluation of potential, temperature and pH, though neither guarantees embrittlement. The guide also reports severe damage from hydrochloric acid cleaning, and fluorides attack titanium. Because titanium is not toxic to marine organisms, it also fouls readily.

How should shell-and-tube exchangers be designed for chloride service?

Tube side or shell side?

Seawater and brine often go in the tubes. Straight tubes can be cleaned mechanically, passes control velocity, and expensive alloy stays in the tubes, tubesheets and channels. That is a preference, not a rule. A high-pressure or hazardous process stream that belongs in the tubes, or an evaporating duty such as a horizontal-tube MED effect, puts the water on the shell side. The shell then becomes wetted alloy, baffle holes add crevices, dead zones collect deposits, and cleaning usually needs a removable bundle.

Velocity, erosion and vibration

Too little velocity lets silt settle and biofilm grow, creating the deposits under which crevice attack starts. Too much raises pressure drop and pumping power, erodes less tolerant materials at tube inlets and, on the shell side, can drive tube vibration. The workable range depends on tube material, solids load and cleaning plan, so velocity must be set with corrosion and fouling in view.

Tubes, tubesheets, channels and gaskets as one system

Mixed-metal construction works when it is designed as a system. Titanium or super duplex tubes may be paired with solid or clad tubesheets and with coated, lined or clad carbon steel channels. Each pairing raises the same questions. Which surface is anodic, and how large is it relative to the cathode? What happens at coating holidays? Could cathodic protection for the steel charge hydrogen into titanium?

Joints concentrate crevices. Expanded joints leave a crevice behind the expanded zone, and whether joints are expanded, welded or both changes where crevices sit. Gasket faces add more. The Journal AWWA guidelines warn that graphite-containing gaskets can initiate severe galvanic attack on stainless steel, so gasket selection must cover crevice geometry as well as chemistry. Dissimilar piping at the nozzles may also need isolation.

Details that decide maintainability

Removable bundles allow shell-side cleaning and inspection; fixed tubesheets do not, and U-bends resist mechanical tube-side cleaning. Differential expansion between dissimilar metals may call for an expansion joint, floating head or U-tubes. Thin-wall titanium tubes are less stiff than steel tubes of the same size, so support spacing must be checked. Vents prevent air pockets where salts concentrate, and drains and manways decide whether a unit can be emptied after hydrotest and inspected.

How do fouling, scaling and brine concentration change the design?

Fouling covers three different problems. Biofouling is living film and growth, controlled with velocity and oxidizing biocides that also raise stainless steel corrosion potential. Mineral scale forms when water chemistry exceeds a salt's solubility. Calcium carbonate becomes less soluble as temperature rises, so it tends to deposit first on heated surfaces. Calcium sulfate precipitation depends on temperature, concentration, salt form (gypsum, hemihydrate or anhydrite) and solution chemistry, while silica depends on pH, temperature and concentration. Solids deposition is silt, sand and corrosion product settling where velocity is low.

Concentration changes scaling and corrosion together. As water is removed, chloride rises, boiling-point elevation raises wall temperatures and sparingly soluble salts approach saturation. Seeded falling-film brine concentrators circulate calcium sulfate crystals so that scale precipitates on the seeds instead of the tubes. Forced-circulation crystallizers are generally arranged so crystals grow in the vessel body rather than in the heater tubes. Materials must be chosen for the most concentrated, hottest point in the train.

An inflated fouling resistance adds surface, and its effect on velocity depends on how the area is added. More tubes per pass or a larger shell lower velocity; longer tubes, more passes or closer baffle spacing can hold it. Where velocity falls, deposition can accelerate, so the hydraulic design should be checked at the oversized condition. An optimistic allowance shortens cleaning intervals. Allowances should rest on plant history and a stated cleaning interval, with cleaning chemicals approved for every wetted alloy and gasket; trending approach temperature and pressure drop shows when performance slips.

Which exchanger type fits chloride service?

Each type trades compactness against fouling tolerance, pressure capability and access, and the duty should decide.

EquipmentTypical chloride-service dutiesStrengthsLimitations
Shell-and-tubeSeawater coolers, brine heaters, condensers, high-pressure or fouling dutiesPressure and temperature capability; tolerates solids; mechanical cleaning; retubing and pluggingLarger footprint and alloy surface for close approaches; shell-side crevices and dead zones
Plate-and-frame (gasketed)Clean seawater cooling and heat recovery, often with titanium platesCompact; close temperature approach; easy to open and extendGasket pressure and temperature limits; many gasket crevices; narrow channels clog with solids
Welded plateClean to moderately fouling duties above gasketed-plate limitsCompact; fewer gasketsLimited mechanical cleaning; harder repair
SpiralSludges, slurries and fouling brinesSingle channel resists clogging; covers open for cleaningSize and pressure limits; specialized repair
Evaporators and condensersThermal desalination, brine concentration, crystallization, steam condensingBuilt for phase change, scaling control and high concentrationPerformance tied to brine chemistry and operating discipline

Table 3. General trade-offs; vendor ratings and project specifications govern actual limits.

What do codes and standards cover, and what do they leave out?

Construction codes govern pressure integrity, not corrosion suitability. ASME Section VIII, Division 1 sets rules for design, materials, fabrication, examination and testing, and Division 2 provides alternative rules with more detailed design analysis. A PHMSA review of the 1992 and 2015 editions summarizes Division 1 as requiring the user or the user's designated agent to specify corrosion allowances. Current wording should be confirmed in the edition named on the contract. TEMA governs shell-and-tube construction details, surface condensers are often specified to Heat Exchange Institute standards, and connecting piping falls under the applicable ASME B31 code.

Material specifications such as ASTM B338 for titanium tubes and ASTM A789 for duplex tubing define product requirements; service suitability remains a separate evaluation.

Common design and procurement mistakes

  • Selecting by chloride ppm alone. Oxygen, chlorine and temperature can make equal-chloride waters behave very differently.

  • Treating 316L as a seawater material. Crevice attack usually follows.

  • Assuming titanium cannot corrode. Hot crevices, fluorides and acid cleaning attack it, and hydrogen uptake can embrittle it under specific conditions.

  • Ignoring crevices and oxidizers. Gasket faces, tube joints and baffle holes start most localized attack; chlorination or cleaning acids can attack otherwise suitable alloys.

  • Specifying tubes but not tubesheets, channels and gaskets. Electrical coupling can make the less noble metal corrode preferentially, depending on potential difference, area ratio, conductivity and service conditions.

  • Using unrealistic fouling allowances. Oversizing can lower velocity and invite deposits, depending on how the area is added; undersizing forces frequent cleaning.

  • Neglecting drainage and access. Equipment that cannot be drained and cleaned collects the deposits that start crevice corrosion.

  • Designing a concentrating process from the feed analysis. Evaporators see the concentrated brine.

  • Treating Code compliance as corrosion approval. A stamped vessel can still be the wrong alloy.

RFQ checklist for seawater and high-chloride heat exchangers

A useful inquiry separates what sizes the exchanger from what keeps it intact.

For thermal sizing

  • Process application, equipment duty and position in the process

  • Flow rates, heat duty and inlet and outlet temperatures on both sides, for every operating case

  • Fluid composition or properties for both streams, including any phase change

  • Allowable pressure drop on each side

  • Fouling resistance basis and the cleaning interval it assumes

  • Preferred fluid allocation, if any

For corrosion and mechanical design

  • Water analysis: chloride, total dissolved and suspended solids, pH at temperature, dissolved oxygen, and scaling ions such as calcium, magnesium, sulfate, alkalinity and silica

  • Oxidants and biocides: residual chlorine and dosing regime (continuous, intermittent or shock), plus sulfides, ammonia or other species that attack specific alloys

  • Water-side wall-temperature range, including startup, upset and cleaning extremes where available

  • Cleaning chemicals, methods and frequency

  • Operating cycles, shutdowns, draining and layup practice

  • Design pressure, temperature and vacuum for each side

  • Material preferences or exclusions, corrosion allowance, and who owns the corrosion design basis

  • Applicable code, jurisdiction and stamping, TEMA class and owner specifications

  • Inspection and testing: examination extent, positive material identification, hydrotest water quality and draining, leak testing, documentation and material traceability

  • Maintenance access: bundle removal, channel covers and spares

The second list needs a named owner, such as the process designer, owner's engineer or corrosion specialist, before materials are fixed.

How Harris Thermal supports high-chloride heat exchanger projects

Harris Thermal designs and fabricates custom shell-and-tube heat exchangers, condensers, falling-film and forced-circulation evaporators, crystallizers and ASME Section VIII, Division 1 pressure vessels for water treatment, desalination, brine concentration and ZLD duties. Thermal and mechanical equipment design is done in-house. Fabrication runs from carbon and stainless steels through duplex, super duplex and 6% molybdenum grades such as AL-6XN to exotic alloys including titanium and nickel alloys.

The process design, water chemistry and corrosion design basis remain with the owner, system designer or corrosion specialist, and Harris designs and builds equipment to the materials and requirements that basis sets. Plate-type exchangers and membrane systems are outside its scope. Sending the RFQ inputs above lets material and configuration questions be settled before quotation.

FAQs about heat exchangers for desalination and high-chloride service

What is the best material for a seawater heat exchanger?

No single material is best. Titanium is widely used for seawater tubes, while super duplex, 6Mo stainless steels and nickel alloys suit many duties. Temperature, oxidants, crevices, cleaning and cost across the whole wetted system decide.

Is 316L stainless steel suitable for seawater heat exchangers?

Generally not for immersed seawater heat-transfer surfaces. Type 316L is prone to crevice and pitting attack under gaskets, deposits and tube joints, especially in warm or chlorinated seawater.

Can titanium heat exchangers corrode?

Yes: crevice corrosion in hot brines, attack by fluorides and some acid cleaners, and hydrogen embrittlement. Hydrogen uptake usually requires a compromised oxide film, a hydrogen source and elevated temperature, although heavy cathodic overprotection can cause it even at ambient temperature. In ambient seawater, titanium is otherwise among the most resistant materials available.

What is PREN, and can it be used to select an alloy?

PREN, commonly %Cr + 3.3 × %Mo + 16 × %N, ranks pitting resistance among similar stainless steels. It ignores welds, microstructure, crevices, temperature and oxidants, so it serves only as a screening tool.

Should seawater go on the tube side or the shell side?

Often the tube side, for mechanical cleaning and to keep costly alloy in tubes, tubesheets and channels. Process pressure, evaporating duties or cleaning plans can justify shell-side water.

Do reverse osmosis desalination plants need heat exchangers?

Not for the separation, which relies on pressure and membranes. Heat exchangers appear for feed temperature control, auxiliary cooling or hybrid membrane-thermal plants.

Ready to start your next project?

Tell us about your application, timeline, and budget — our engineering team will help you get it built right the first time.